Quill’s Quandary by Barbara Goss

Once the flame of love is lit, it cannot be extinguished.
Having withdrawn from society, Quill Gentry’s normal response to unexpected visitors is a warning blast from his shotgun. Somehow a beautiful stranger with a limp breaches his defenses and he begins to come out of his shell. Then Genevieve abruptly disappears. Thinking Quill just needs a wife, his preacher arranges a mail-order bride for him. But, the very day the gorgeous Lillian arrives, Quill learns from Genevieve of her imminent return and why she’d left so abruptly. Now Quill has a quandary.